Carlisle, located in Sullivan County, Indiana, is a small yet charming town known for its friendly community, rich history, and tranquil living environment. Surrounded by picturesque landscapes and providing easy access to local services, Carlisle is an excellent choice for families and individuals seeking a peaceful lifestyle while still being within reach of urban conveniences. This article presents the best residential areas in Carlisle, detailing their characteristics, housing options, and average prices.
Table of Contents
Downtown Carlisle
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Downtown Carlisle serves as the cultural hub of the town, filled with local shops, restaurants, and community events. This area promotes a strong sense of community and is perfect for those who appreciate urban conveniences.
Characteristics of the Downtown Carlisle
* Culture: Local art galleries, community festivals, and farmers markets
* Transportation: Walkable area with access to public transportation
* Services: Grocery stores, schools, medical clinics, and banking services
* Environment: Friendly and engaging community atmosphere
Housing Options in the Downtown Carlisle
Historic homes, Single-family homes, Apartments
Average Home Prices in the Downtown Carlisle
* Buying: $120,000 – $180,000
* Renting: $850 – $1,200/month
Lake Sullivan Area
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The Lake Sullivan area is perfect for nature enthusiasts and those seeking outdoor recreational activities. Residents can enjoy swimming, fishing, and leisurely walks along the waterfront, providing a relaxed and scenic atmosphere.
Characteristics of the Lake Sullivan Area
* Culture: Water-based activities, outdoor sports, and seasonal events
* Transportation: Car is recommended; scenic road access
* Services: Limited to essential services; nearby access to more in Sullivan
* Environment: Tranquil and nature-oriented
Housing Options in the Lake Sullivan Area
Lakefront cabins, Single-family homes
Average Home Prices in the Lake Sullivan Area
* Buying: $150,000 – $210,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,600/month
Carlisle Heights
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Carlisle Heights offers a suburban feel with spacious lots and family-friendly amenities. This neighborhood is popular for its schools and parks, making it an excellent option for families with children.
Characteristics of the Carlisle Heights
* Culture: Family-centered community with access to parks and recreational areas
* Transportation: Car-dependent; local public transport options available
* Services: Nearby schools, playgrounds, and family healthcare facilities
* Environment: Safe and welcoming for families
Housing Options in the Carlisle Heights
Single-family homes, Duplexes
Average Home Prices in the Carlisle Heights
* Buying: $130,000 – $190,000
* Renting: $950 – $1,300/month
Hi Nella Estates
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Hi Nella Estates features beautiful homes in a scenic environment, perfect for buyers who prefer a suburban lifestyle. The community prides itself on its peaceful ambiance and well-maintained properties.
Characteristics of the Hi Nella Estates
* Culture: Community events and social gatherings
* Transportation: Car essential, with easy access to highways
* Services: Local shops and access to larger retail in surrounding areas
* Environment: Quiet and family-oriented
Housing Options in the Hi Nella Estates
Single-family homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Hi Nella Estates
* Buying: $145,000 – $210,000
* Renting: $900 – $1,250/month
Sullivan County Park Area
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
This area offers proximity to parks and nature reserves, making it an excellent choice for those who enjoy outdoor life and recreational activities. The community is ideal for families and nature lovers.
Characteristics of the Sullivan County Park Area
* Culture: Outdoor enthusiasts, wildlife observation, and community outdoor events
* Transportation: Car recommended; easy access to regional parks
* Services: Limited amenities; greater access in nearby Sullivan
* Environment: Nature-focused and active
Housing Options in the Sullivan County Park Area
Ranch-style homes, Modular homes
Average Home Prices in the Sullivan County Park Area
* Buying: $110,000 – $170,000
* Renting: $800 – $1,100/month
East Carlisle
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
East Carlisle is known for its spacious homes and rural atmosphere, perfect for families looking for a bit of distance from the city. The area promotes a relaxed lifestyle with ample space for children and pets.
Characteristics of the East Carlisle
* Culture: Rural lifestyle and community events
* Transportation: Car essential; quiet country roads
* Services: Basic local shops, wider offerings in Carlisle and Sullivan
* Environment: Peaceful rural setting
Housing Options in the East Carlisle
Farmhouses, Single-family homes, Larger estates
Average Home Prices in the East Carlisle
* Buying: $135,000 – $200,000
* Renting: $850 – $1,150/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Carlisle:
The best residential areas in Carlisle include Downtown Carlisle, Lake Sullivan Area, Carlisle Heights, Hi Nella Estates, Sullivan County Park Area, and East Carlisle.
Carlisle Heights is particularly family-friendly, offering good schools, parks, and a quiet environment.
The Lake Sullivan Area and Sullivan County Park Area are both excellent for outdoor activities, including fishing, hiking, and community events.
In Downtown Carlisle, average housing prices range from $120,000 to $180,000 for homes, with an average rental price of $850 to $1,200/month.
Public transport options are limited, and having a car is recommended for better accessibility.
The Lake Sullivan area offers lakefront cabins and single-family homes, usually ranging from $150,000 to $210,000 to buy.
Yes, there are various community events in Carlisle, especially in Downtown Carlisle, such as farmers markets and festivals.
East Carlisle and Sullivan County Park Area tend to have more affordable rental options, ranging from $800 to $1,100/month.
Carlisle has a decent school system with good ratings and a supportive community, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.
Hi Nella Estates has local shops and access to larger retail outlets nearby, providing essential services to residents.
Living in Carlisle offers a friendly, small-town atmosphere with a strong sense of community, family values, and access to nature.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Carlisle:
Carlisle, Indiana, presents diverse residential neighborhoods each with its distinct charm and benefits. From the lively Downtown Carlisle, rich in culture and local events, to the serene and nature-oriented Lake Sullivan Area, the town caters to various lifestyle preferences. Families will find supportive environments in areas like Carlisle Heights and Hi Nella Estates, while nature lovers can appreciate the tranquility of Sullivan County Park and East Carlisle. With limited but convenient services, Carlisle ensures a peaceful and satisfying living experience that balances rural charm with community spirit. Choosing the right area will depend on individual needs, preferences, and lifestyle, making Carlisle an ideal home for anyone looking to enjoy a quiet yet fulfilling life.
About the Author
Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.