Herkimer, located in the heart of New York State, is a charming village known for its rich history, beautiful landscapes, and community spirit. The area features diverse residential options suitable for families, young professionals, and retirees alike. With its historic sites, vibrant downtown, and proximity to outdoor activities, Herkimer offers a unique blend of small-town charm and accessibility to urban amenities. This article elaborates on the best residential areas to live in Herkimer, highlighting their characteristics, housing options, and average prices.
Table of Contents
Downtown Herkimer

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Downtown Herkimer serves as the main hub of the village, offering a mix of historic architecture, local shops, and restaurants. Residents enjoy a rich community life with regular events and festivals. The area is perfect for those who appreciate cultural experiences and easy access to essentials.
Characteristics of the Downtown Herkimer
* Culture: Close-knit community with local theater and art galleries
* Transportation: Walkable area with access to public transport and nearby highways
* Services: Grocery stores, cafes, banks, and community services
* Environment: Vibrant and bustling, with a friendly atmosphere
Housing Options in the Downtown Herkimer
Historic homes, Apartments, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Downtown Herkimer
* Buying: $130,000 – $180,000
* Renting: $900 – $1,400/month
East Herkimer

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
East Herkimer is known for its residential tranquility and suburban feel. This area is ideal for families looking for safe neighborhoods, parks, and good schools. East Herkimer is surrounded by nature, providing ample opportunities for outdoor activities.
Characteristics of the East Herkimer
* Culture: Family-oriented community with local parks and schools
* Transportation: Car recommended, with nearby access to highways
* Services: Family-friendly amenities, schools, and playgrounds
* Environment: Peaceful and friendly, with a suburban layout
Housing Options in the East Herkimer
Single-family homes, Duplexes
Average Home Prices in the East Herkimer
* Buying: $150,000 – $220,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,600/month
West Herkimer

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
West Herkimer is known for its spacious homes and larger lots, making it attractive for those who enjoy having more outdoor space. The area retains a rural aesthetic while still being close to city amenities. This zone is great for gardening enthusiasts and nature lovers.
Characteristics of the West Herkimer
* Culture: Rural charm with community events and local farm markets
* Transportation: Car essential for commuting
* Services: Limited basic amenities, but close to downtown services
* Environment: Serene, spacious, and family-friendly
Housing Options in the West Herkimer
Single-family homes, Ranch-style houses
Average Home Prices in the West Herkimer
* Buying: $160,000 – $240,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,500/month
Northeast Herkimer

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Northeast Herkimer features newer developments and modern housing options. This area attracts young professionals and families looking for contemporary living spaces with easy access to downtown.
Characteristics of the Northeast Herkimer
* Culture: Modern community with a focus on outdoor activities
* Transportation: Easy access to main roads and public transport
* Services: Shopping centers and recreational parks nearby
* Environment: Lively and contemporary, with a growing community
Housing Options in the Northeast Herkimer
Newly built homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Northeast Herkimer
* Buying: $190,000 – $300,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month
Herkimer County Historical Society Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Home to the Herkimer County Historical Society, this area offers a peaceful environment with access to local history and culture. The proximity to local museums and parks enhances the appeal for those interested in heritage.
Characteristics of the Herkimer County Historical Society Area
* Culture: Rich historical significance with cultural events
* Transportation: Convenient access to main roads and local transit
* Services: Local museums, community centers, and parks
* Environment: Quiet and cultural, surrounded by history
Housing Options in the Herkimer County Historical Society Area
Historic homes, Victorian-style houses
Average Home Prices in the Herkimer County Historical Society Area
* Buying: $140,000 – $200,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,500/month
South Herkimer

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
South Herkimer maintains a strong community vibe with a selection of well-maintained homes and neighborhood parks. This area is close to the Mohawk River, providing opportunities for recreation and leisure activities.
Characteristics of the South Herkimer
* Culture: Community-oriented with outdoor activities and river access
* Transportation: Easy access to public transportation and highways
* Services: Access to grocery stores and local businesses
* Environment: Friendly, community-focused, and active
Housing Options in the South Herkimer
Single-family homes, Bungalows
Average Home Prices in the South Herkimer
* Buying: $120,000 – $180,000
* Renting: $950 – $1,400/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Herkimer:
The best residential areas in Herkimer include Downtown Herkimer, East Herkimer, West Herkimer, Northeast Herkimer, the Herkimer County Historical Society Area, and South Herkimer.
East Herkimer is considered the most family-friendly due to its safe neighborhoods, parks, and schools.
Northeast Herkimer offers modern housing developments, while Downtown Herkimer features historic homes and apartments.
Average home prices in Herkimer range from $120,000 in some areas to $300,000 in newer developments.
Yes, Herkimer has several good schools, particularly in East Herkimer, which is known for family-friendly amenities.
Downtown Herkimer has the best access to public transport and is also walkable for everyday needs.
Herkimer is generally considered a safe place to live, with strong community ties and active neighborhood watches.
Outdoor activities in Herkimer include hiking, fishing in the Mohawk River, and visiting local parks.
Yes, Downtown Herkimer and Northeast Herkimer have shopping centers and local businesses, providing various retail options.
Northeast Herkimer has a lively ambiance with a growing community, modern amenities, and a focus on outdoor activities.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Herkimer:
Herkimer is a vibrant village that offers a diverse range of residential areas suitable for different lifestyles. Whether you prefer the cultural richness of Downtown Herkimer, the suburban feel of East Herkimer, or the modern amenities of Northeast Herkimer, there is something for everyone. The historical significance and natural beauty of the region further enhance the appeal of living here. With strong community ties, good schools, and access to recreational activities, Herkimer presents an attractive option for both families and individuals seeking a fulfilling living experience.
About the Author

Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.