Mount Pleasant Mills, a quaint community in Snyder County, Pennsylvania, offers a peaceful rural lifestyle combined with access to essential amenities and outdoor activities. Surrounded by farmland and scenic beauty, this area is ideal for families and individuals seeking a tight-knit community with a slower pace of life. This article explores the best residential areas in Mount Pleasant Mills, outlining their unique characteristics, housing options, and average prices.
Table of Contents
Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The heart of the community, Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills boasts a welcoming atmosphere with easy access to local shops, eateries, and essential services. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a community vibe and want to be close to the action.
Characteristics of the Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills
* Culture: Local events, farmers' markets, and community gatherings
* Transportation: Public transport available, easy to walk around
* Services: Grocery stores, restaurants, and small businesses
* Environment: Friendly and community-focused
Housing Options in the Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills
Single-family homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills
* Buying: $150,000 – $250,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,500/month
Bentonville

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Located just a short drive from Downtown, Bentonville is known for its spacious lots and serene surroundings. This area is perfect for families and those seeking a more secluded lifestyle while still being close to amenities.
Characteristics of the Bentonville
* Culture: Community events, family-oriented activities
* Transportation: Car is necessary for travel to amenities
* Services: Nearby schools, parks, and recreational areas
* Environment: Quiet and family-friendly
Housing Options in the Bentonville
Larger single-family homes, New constructions
Average Home Prices in the Bentonville
* Buying: $200,000 – $300,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month
Middleburg Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Middleburg is a vibrant community nearby that offers a mix of small-town charm and modern conveniences. It features a variety of housing options and is a hub for local events and activities.
Characteristics of the Middleburg Area
* Culture: Historical sites, community fairs, and local festivals
* Transportation: Good road access, ample parking space
* Services: Schools, healthcare facilities, and shopping centers
* Environment: Lively and engaging
Housing Options in the Middleburg Area
Single-family homes, Apartments
Average Home Prices in the Middleburg Area
* Buying: $175,000 – $250,000
* Renting: $900 – $1,400/month
Humble Hill

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
A picturesque area characterized by rolling hills and beautiful landscapes. Humble Hill is perfect for those who love nature and outdoor pursuits, providing access to hiking, biking, and scenic views.
Characteristics of the Humble Hill
* Culture: Focus on outdoor activities and eco-friendly living
* Transportation: Car necessary, limited public transportation
* Services: Essential amenities available, close to nature trails
* Environment: Calm and natural
Housing Options in the Humble Hill
Single-family homes, Cabins
Average Home Prices in the Humble Hill
* Buying: $180,000 – $275,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,600/month
Wagner Valley

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Wagner Valley is known for its wine and orchards, making it a unique residential area. It offers a blend of agriculture and residential options, ideal for those who appreciate rural living.
Characteristics of the Wagner Valley
* Culture: Agri-tourism, wine-tasting events, and local markets
* Transportation: Car is essential for navigating the area
* Services: Limited, few shops, and local farms
* Environment: Agricultural and rustic
Housing Options in the Wagner Valley
Farmhouses, Single-family homes
Average Home Prices in the Wagner Valley
* Buying: $160,000 – $230,000
* Renting: $900 – $1,300/month
Eversberg

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Eversberg is a quaint neighborhood offering a mix of rural and suburban living. It provides affordable housing options, making it an attractive choice for first-time homebuyers and families.
Characteristics of the Eversberg
* Culture: Community-oriented, local clubs and organizations
* Transportation: Car necessary for reaching larger towns
* Services: Basic amenities with access to nearby towns for shopping
* Environment: Family-friendly and cozy
Housing Options in the Eversberg
Starter homes, Duplexes
Average Home Prices in the Eversberg
* Buying: $140,000 – $210,000
* Renting: $800 – $1,200/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Mount Pleasant Mills:
The best residential areas include Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills, Bentonville, Middleburg Area, Humble Hill, Wagner Valley, and Eversberg.
Bentonville is known for its spacious lots and quiet atmosphere, making it great for families.
Eversberg offers some of the most affordable homes in the area, ideal for first-time buyers.
Middleburg features schools, healthcare facilities, and shopping centers, creating a well-rounded community.
Humble Hill provides excellent access to nature trails, hiking, and outdoor activities.
Public transport is limited, and a car is generally necessary to navigate the area efficiently.
Average housing costs vary from about $140,000 to $300,000 depending on the neighborhood.
Bentonville offers larger single-family homes and new constructions, perfect for families.
Yes, the community hosts farmers' markets, festivals, and other local events regularly.
Downtown Mount Pleasant Mills is known for its strong community ties and friendly atmosphere.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Mount Pleasant Mills:
Mount Pleasant Mills offers a diverse array of residential neighborhoods, each with its own unique appeal. Whether you're seeking the community-oriented vibe of Downtown, the serene landscapes of Humble Hill, or the agricultural charm of Wagner Valley, there is something to suit everyone's preferences. With affordable housing options, access to nature, and a variety of local amenities, Mount Pleasant Mills is an ideal place for families, retirees, and individuals looking to escape urban living while still enjoying essential services.
About the Author

Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.