Sheridan, located in Chautauqua County, New York, is a peaceful town characterized by its rural charm, welcoming community, and proximity to Lake Erie. It offers a blend of outdoor recreational activities, local culture, and historical significance, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and individuals seeking a quieter lifestyle. This article explores the best residential areas in Sheridan, highlighting their unique characteristics, housing options, and average prices.
Table of Contents
Downtown Sheridan

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Downtown Sheridan is the town's center, offering a blend of local shops, restaurants, and community events. Its proximity to services and community amenities makes it a vibrant area for those looking to immerse themselves in small-town life.
Characteristics of the Downtown Sheridan
* Culture: Rich local culture with community events and festivals
* Transportation: Well-connected by roads, minimal public transport
* Services: Local grocery stores, post office, and community center
* Environment: Friendly and community-oriented
Housing Options in the Downtown Sheridan
Single-family homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Downtown Sheridan
* Buying: $180,000 – $250,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,600/month
Sheridan Heights

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Sheridan Heights is a suburban neighborhood known for its spacious lots and scenic views. It's ideal for families seeking tranquility while still being close to the amenities of downtown.
Characteristics of the Sheridan Heights
* Culture: Family-friendly atmosphere with parks and recreational activities
* Transportation: Car recommended, community roads
* Services: Nearby schools and parks
* Environment: Quiet and spacious
Housing Options in the Sheridan Heights
Single-family homes, New constructions
Average Home Prices in the Sheridan Heights
* Buying: $220,000 – $300,000
* Renting: $1,500 – $2,000/month
Lake Erie Shores

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Lake Erie Shores offers houses with breathtaking waterfront views, perfect for those who appreciate the beauty of nature and outdoor activities like fishing and boating.
Characteristics of the Lake Erie Shores
* Culture: Strong community focus on outdoor recreation
* Transportation: Limited public transport, a vehicle is needed
* Services: Marinas and local shops nearby
* Environment: Relaxed and scenic
Housing Options in the Lake Erie Shores
Waterfront homes, Cabins
Average Home Prices in the Lake Erie Shores
* Buying: $300,000 – $500,000
* Renting: $2,000 – $2,800/month
Pine Valley

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The Pine Valley area is surrounded by nature, making it ideal for those who love hiking, nature walks, and peace. It has a strong sense of community and is perfect for nature lovers.
Characteristics of the Pine Valley
* Culture: Nature conservation and wildlife observation
* Transportation: Car essential, rural roads
* Services: Minimal, focused on self-sufficient living
* Environment: Tranquil and natural
Housing Options in the Pine Valley
Custom-built homes, Cabins
Average Home Prices in the Pine Valley
* Buying: $190,000 – $250,000
* Renting: $1,100 – $1,500/month
Sheridan Farms

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Sheridan Farms is a rural area known for its agricultural heritage and open spaces. It's ideal for those wanting a more rural lifestyle with an opportunity for farming or gardening.
Characteristics of the Sheridan Farms
* Culture: Agricultural lifestyle with community-supported agriculture
* Transportation: Rural roads, vehicle needed
* Services: Markets, farm stands in the vicinity
* Environment: Quiet and country-like
Housing Options in the Sheridan Farms
Farmhouses, Large lots
Average Home Prices in the Sheridan Farms
* Buying: $170,000 – $240,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,400/month
Maple Run

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Maple Run is known for its tree-lined streets and friendly atmosphere, making it an excellent choice for families. With parks and recreational areas, it invites outdoor activities and community bonding.
Characteristics of the Maple Run
* Culture: Community events and family-centric activities
* Transportation: Car needed, local connectivity
* Services: Schools, parks, and local shops available
* Environment: Friendly and sociable
Housing Options in the Maple Run
Single-family homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Maple Run
* Buying: $200,000 – $280,000
* Renting: $1,300 – $1,700/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Sheridan:
The best residential areas in Sheridan include Downtown Sheridan, Sheridan Heights, Lake Erie Shores, Pine Valley, Sheridan Farms, and Maple Run.
Sheridan Heights and Maple Run are both great family-friendly neighborhoods with access to parks and schools.
Lake Erie Shores offers stunning waterfront homes ideal for those who value proximity to water activities.
Housing prices in Sheridan vary by area, ranging from $170,000 to $500,000 for purchasing homes.
Yes, rental options are available, with prices averaging between $1,000 and $2,800 per month depending on the area.
Public transport options are limited, and residents typically rely on personal vehicles for transportation.
Sheridan offers a variety of outdoor recreational activities, particularly in areas near Lake Erie for fishing, boating, and hiking.
Sheridan has a friendly and welcoming community vibe, with many local events and activities that promote community bonding.
Sheridan Farms tends to offer more affordable housing options compared to other areas.
Sheridan is served by a local school district that has a good reputation, particularly in family-centered neighborhoods like Sheridan Heights.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Sheridan:
Sheridan, NY, offers diverse residential areas catering to various lifestyles, from the vibrant community of Downtown Sheridan to the serenity of Lake Erie Shores and Pine Valley. Each neighborhood presents unique characteristics, making it crucial for prospective homeowners or renters to consider their preferences and needs. Families might find Sheridan Heights and Maple Run particularly appealing, while nature lovers may gravitate towards Pine Valley. Overall, Sheridan presents a compelling blend of community spirit, natural beauty, and a peaceful lifestyle suitable for anyone looking to enjoy life in Western New York.
About the Author

Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.