Sag Harbor, located in Suffolk County on Long Island, is a charming village known for its rich maritime history, vibrant arts scene, and stunning waterfront views. This quaint community is renowned for its unique combination of historic architecture and modern amenities, providing residents with a picturesque coastal lifestyle. In this article, we explore the best residential areas in Sag Harbor, detailing their distinct characteristics, housing options, and average prices.
Table of Contents
Historic District
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The Historic District of Sag Harbor is famous for its well-preserved 19th-century homes and charming streets. This area offers a true sense of community and a rich cultural atmosphere, making it a desirable place for families and individuals alike.
Characteristics of the Historic District
* Culture: Rich maritime history, art galleries, and theaters
* Transportation: Easily walkable; public transport options available
* Services: Local shops, cafes, restaurants, and public parks
* Environment: Quaint, vibrant, and artistic
Housing Options in the Historic District
Single-family homes, townhouses, and historic condos
Average Home Prices in the Historic District
* Buying: $1,200,000 – $2,500,000
* Renting: $3,000 – $10,000/month
North Haven
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
North Haven is a suburban enclave located just north of Sag Harbor, offering a peaceful retreat with expansive properties and serene surroundings. The area is attractive to those looking for larger homes with gardens, while still being close to the village amenities.
Characteristics of the North Haven
* Culture: Family-friendly, outdoor activities, and nature trails
* Transportation: Car recommended; limited public transport
* Services: Grocery stores, local businesses, and parks
* Environment: Quiet, suburban, and nature-oriented
Housing Options in the North Haven
Single-family homes on large lots
Average Home Prices in the North Haven
* Buying: $1,000,000 – $3,000,000
* Renting: $4,000 – $12,000/month
Sag Harbor Waterfront
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The waterfront area of Sag Harbor is characterized by stunning views of the harbor and easy access to boating and water activities. This area is ideal for those who appreciate an oceanfront lifestyle and want to be near the beach.
Characteristics of the Sag Harbor Waterfront
* Culture: Water-based activities, yachting, and seafood dining
* Transportation: Bicycle-friendly and walkable, public transport available
* Services: Marinas, restaurants, and waterfront parks
* Environment: Relaxed, scenic, and vibrant
Housing Options in the Sag Harbor Waterfront
Waterfront homes, condos, and cottages
Average Home Prices in the Sag Harbor Waterfront
* Buying: $1,500,000 – $4,500,000
* Renting: $5,000 – $15,000/month
Bay Point
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Bay Point is a peaceful residential area features a mix of stylish homes and quaint cottages, with a strong sense of community. This neighborhood is known for its proximity to beaches and recreational opportunities, making it popular with families.
Characteristics of the Bay Point
* Culture: Family-oriented, community events, and outdoor activities
* Transportation: Car essential; limited public transport
* Services: Local markets, schools, and playgrounds
* Environment: Friendly, welcoming, and safe
Housing Options in the Bay Point
Single-family homes, seasonal cottages
Average Home Prices in the Bay Point
* Buying: $900,000 – $2,000,000
* Renting: $3,500 – $8,500/month
Mashashimuet Park
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Mashashimuet Park is an emerging residential area known for its proximity to the park of the same name, offering ample green space and recreational facilities. This neighborhood is appealing to those who enjoy outdoor activities and an active lifestyle.
Characteristics of the Mashashimuet Park
* Culture: Recreation-focused, community sports events, family-friendly
* Transportation: Easily accessible by foot or bike; limited public transport
* Services: Parks, recreational facilities, and nearby shops
* Environment: Active, engaging, and family-oriented
Housing Options in the Mashashimuet Park
Modern homes, townhouses, and apartments
Average Home Prices in the Mashashimuet Park
* Buying: $800,000 – $2,000,000
* Renting: $3,000 – $7,000/month
Little Plains Street
(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Little Plains Street is a charming residential area that offers quaint homes along tree-lined streets. It is well-suited for families and individuals seeking a quieter ambiance while still being within walking distance of the village.
Characteristics of the Little Plains Street
* Culture: Close community, local dining, and shops
* Transportation: Walking-friendly; accessible by car
* Services: Local boutiques, restaurants, and cafes
* Environment: Cordial, friendly, and community-oriented
Housing Options in the Little Plains Street
Victorian homes, single-family dwellings
Average Home Prices in the Little Plains Street
* Buying: $1,000,000 – $2,200,000
* Renting: $3,500 – $9,000/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Sag Harbor:
The best residential areas in Sag Harbor include the Historic District, North Haven, Sag Harbor Waterfront, Bay Point, Mashashimuet Park, and Little Plains Street.
North Haven and Bay Point are particularly family-friendly, offering ample space and community activities suitable for children.
Sag Harbor Waterfront is the prime area for waterfront properties, providing stunning bay views and direct access to boating.
Average home prices in Sag Harbor typically range from $800,000 to $4.5 million, depending on the area and property type.
Yes, Sag Harbor has a variety of rental options, ranging from $3,000 to $15,000 per month, depending on the area and property size.
Public transportation is limited, but there are some local bus services available, and many areas are walkable or bicycle-friendly.
The Historic District is known for its vibrant nightlife, featuring various restaurants, bars, and cultural events.
Bay Point and Mashashimuet Park are both known for their community-oriented events and recreational opportunities.
Housing options in Sag Harbor include single-family homes, condos, townhouses, and seasonal cottages.
Consider proximity to schools, community services, availability of recreational activities, and personal lifestyle preferences.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Sag Harbor:
Sag Harbor is a beautiful and diverse village offering a variety of residential options for families, retirees, and young professionals alike. With its historic charm, waterfront appeal, and vibrant community life, each neighborhood possesses its unique characteristics catering to different lifestyles. Whether you prefer the artistic ambiance of the Historic District, the tranquility of North Haven, or the lively waterfront of Sag Harbor, this village promises an enriching living experience. Explore your options, and you'll find the ideal place to call home in Sag Harbor.
About the Author
Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.