Best Residential Neighborhoods in Old Forge, Herkimer County, NY



Best Residential Neighborhoods in Old Forge, Herkimer County, NY

(Image for illustration purposes only.)



Old Forge is a charming town located in Herkimer County, New York, nestled in the breathtaking Adirondack Mountains. Known for its beautiful landscapes, vibrant local culture, and rich history, Old Forge is a sought-after destination for both year-round residents and seasonal visitors. This article explores the best residential areas in Old Forge, highlighting their unique characteristics, housing options, and average prices, making it an ideal resource for those looking to settle in this picturesque region.

Table of Contents



    Old Forge Village



    Old Forge Village

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    Old Forge Village is the heartbeat of the town, offering a warm community atmosphere with a variety of shops, restaurants, and local events. Residents enjoy the convenience of being close to amenities and recreational activities.



    Characteristics of the Old Forge Village

    * Culture: Art galleries, music festivals, and local markets

    * Transportation: Walking-friendly with available parking; public transport options are limited

    * Services: Grocery stores, cafes, restaurants, and health services

    * Environment: Lively yet quaint, with a strong sense of community


    Housing Options in the Old Forge Village

    Single-family homes, Condos, Cabins


    Average Home Prices in the Old Forge Village

    * Buying: $250,000 – $400,000

    * Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month



    Lakefront Neighborhood



    Lakefront Neighborhood

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    The Lakefront Neighborhood offers stunning views of Fourth Lake and easy access to water sports and fishing. This area is ideal for those seeking recreation and a tranquil lifestyle by the water.



    Characteristics of the Lakefront Neighborhood

    * Culture: Waterfront activities, fishing, and boating culture

    * Transportation: Car is necessary; limited public transport

    * Services: Restaurants, small convenience stores, and boat launches

    * Environment: Relaxed and scenic, perfect for nature enthusiasts


    Housing Options in the Lakefront Neighborhood

    Lakefront homes, Vacation rentals, Seasonal cottages


    Average Home Prices in the Lakefront Neighborhood

    * Buying: $300,000 – $600,000

    * Renting: $1,500 – $2,500/month



    Big Moose Area



    Big Moose Area

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    The Big Moose Area is a more secluded spot, perfect for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle. It features beautiful woodlands and is close to hiking trails and winter sports, making it ideal for outdoor lovers.



    Characteristics of the Big Moose Area

    * Culture: Nature conservation, outdoor adventure, and solitude

    * Transportation: Car essential; minimal public transport

    * Services: Few local amenities; mostly self-sufficient living

    * Environment: Quiet, surrounded by nature, and ideal for privacy


    Housing Options in the Big Moose Area

    Cabins, Single-family homes, Seasonal homes


    Average Home Prices in the Big Moose Area

    * Buying: $200,000 – $350,000

    * Renting: $1,000 – $1,500/month



    Inlet Village



    Inlet Village

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    Adjacent to Old Forge, Inlet Village is charming and offers a friendly small-town vibe. This area is well known for its outdoor recreation, including hiking, snowmobiling, and scenic views, making it perfect for adventure enthusiasts.



    Characteristics of the Inlet Village

    * Culture: Outdoor events, community gatherings, and recreational activities

    * Transportation: Car is necessary; limited public transport

    * Services: Basic amenities including grocery stores and local eateries

    * Environment: Community-focused with easy access to nature


    Housing Options in the Inlet Village

    Single-family homes, Townhouses, Cabins


    Average Home Prices in the Inlet Village

    * Buying: $225,000 – $375,000

    * Renting: $1,100 – $1,700/month



    White Lake Area



    White Lake Area

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    The White Lake Area is known for its privacy and beautiful landscapes. It is great for families and retirees who appreciate a slower-paced lifestyle with close access to various outdoor recreational options.



    Characteristics of the White Lake Area

    * Culture: Family-oriented activities and community events

    * Transportation: Car required for most activities

    * Services: Limited amenities, primarily necessities; more available in nearby towns

    * Environment: Peaceful and family-friendly


    Housing Options in the White Lake Area

    Single-family homes, Larger lots for privacy


    Average Home Prices in the White Lake Area

    * Buying: $250,000 – $450,000

    * Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month



    Moose River Plains



    Moose River Plains

    (Image for illustration purposes only.)


    The Moose River Plains area offers a rugged lifestyle surrounded by untouched nature. This area attracts those seeking adventure and a strong connection to the outdoors, with ample opportunities for hiking, fishing, and hunting.



    Characteristics of the Moose River Plains

    * Culture: Outdoor enthusiasts, hunting, and fishing culture

    * Transportation: Car is a must; very few public transport options

    * Services: Minimal services; primarily self-sufficient

    * Environment: Remote and tranquil, perfect for seclusion


    Housing Options in the Moose River Plains

    Cabins, Modular homes, Custom built houses


    Average Home Prices in the Moose River Plains

    * Buying: $180,000 – $300,000

    * Renting: $900 – $1,400/month



    Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Old Forge:



    The best residential areas in Old Forge include Old Forge Village, Lakefront Neighborhood, Big Moose Area, Inlet Village, White Lake Area, and Moose River Plains.

    Old Forge Village and White Lake Area are both popular choices among families due to their community-focused atmosphere and access to amenities.

    Homes in Old Forge Village generally range from $250,000 to $400,000, depending on size and location.

    Yes, the Lakefront Neighborhood provides fantastic recreational opportunities and stunning views, albeit at a higher price point, with homes averaging $300,000 to $600,000.

    Yes, many seasonal properties and vacation rentals can be found, especially in the Lakefront Neighborhood and Big Moose Area.

    Transportation options are limited. A personal vehicle is necessary for most areas, as public transport services are minimal.

    The Big Moose Area and Moose River Plains are well known for outdoor activities like hiking, fishing, and snowmobiling, making them ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.

    Inlet Village has basic amenities, including grocery stores and local eateries, making it convenient for residents.

    Yes, Old Forge boasts a strong sense of community, with numerous events and cultural activities throughout the year.

    The Lakefront Neighborhood has a scenic and relaxed atmosphere, perfect for those who appreciate nature and outdoor recreation.



    Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Old Forge:

    Old Forge, situated in the heart of the Adirondacks, offers a diverse range of residential areas to suit different preferences and lifestyles. From the vibrant Old Forge Village with its local amenities and community spirit to the serene Lakefront Neighborhood perfect for water enthusiasts, each area has its unique charm. The Big Moose Area and Moose River Plains attract outdoor adventurers, while Inlet Village and White Lake Area cater to families and those seeking a friendly environment. Overall, Old Forge presents an ideal blend of natural beauty, outdoor activities, and close-knit community living, making it an attractive place to call home.

    About the Author
    Eribert De Oliveira
    Published by:Eribert De Oliveira

    Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.