Fishtail, located in Stillwater County, Montana, is a small, charming community surrounded by stunning natural scenery, including mountains, lakes, and rivers. Known for its friendly atmosphere and outdoor recreational opportunities, Fishtail offers a peaceful lifestyle ideal for nature lovers, families, and anyone looking to escape urban hustle. This article explores the best residential areas in Fishtail, highlighting their unique characteristics, housing options, average prices, and the community's overall appeal.
Table of Contents
Fishtail Village

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Fishtail Village is the heart of the community, where you can find local shops, family-friendly parks, and access to recreational activities. This area is perfect for families and individuals who appreciate a close-knit community.
Characteristics of the Fishtail Village
* Culture: Community events and local art
* Transportation: Dependable local transport, bike-friendly paths
* Services: Grocery stores, cafes, schools, and health services
* Environment: Warm and welcoming
Housing Options in the Fishtail Village
Single-family homes, Townhouses
Average Home Prices in the Fishtail Village
* Buying: $250,000 – $350,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month
Fishtail Creek Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The Fishtail Creek Area is known for its tranquil environment and scenic beauty. With beautiful creekside properties, it is ideal for those seeking peace and serenity while enjoying nature.
Characteristics of the Fishtail Creek Area
* Culture: Nature-centric, wildlife observation
* Transportation: Car necessary, remote but accessible
* Services: Limited local amenities, proximity to Fishtail Village services
* Environment: Secluded and quiet
Housing Options in the Fishtail Creek Area
Lakeside cabins, Custom-built homes
Average Home Prices in the Fishtail Creek Area
* Buying: $300,000 – $450,000
* Renting: $1,500 – $2,200/month
Yellowstone Valley Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
This area near Yellowstone Valley offers stunning views of the Absaroka-Beartooth Mountains and fertile land. It is perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and those who love rural life.
Characteristics of the Yellowstone Valley Area
* Culture: Agricultural heritage and outdoor sports
* Transportation: Car essential, local roads in good condition
* Services: Farmers' markets, artisanal shops, local diner
* Environment: Down-to-earth and community-oriented
Housing Options in the Yellowstone Valley Area
Ranch-style homes, Larger plots of land
Average Home Prices in the Yellowstone Valley Area
* Buying: $280,000 – $400,000
* Renting: $1,300 – $1,900/month
Rocky Mountain Estates

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
Rocky Mountain Estates is a newer residential area offering modern housing. It combines the convenience of contemporary living with easy access to outdoor activities.
Characteristics of the Rocky Mountain Estates
* Culture: Modern lifestyle with community focus
* Transportation: Well-connected with local transport options
* Services: New schools, fitness centers, grocery chains
* Environment: Vibrant and family-friendly
Housing Options in the Rocky Mountain Estates
Modern single-family homes, Condos
Average Home Prices in the Rocky Mountain Estates
* Buying: $350,000 – $500,000
* Renting: $1,700 – $2,500/month
Custer Gallatin National Forest Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
This area provides direct access to stunning natural landscapes and outdoor activities. It's ideal for avid hikers, hunters, and anyone who loves spending time in nature.
Characteristics of the Custer Gallatin National Forest Area
* Culture: Outdoor recreation and exploration
* Transportation: Car necessary, remote nature trails
* Services: Limited, but access to camping facilities
* Environment: Rustic and adventurous
Housing Options in the Custer Gallatin National Forest Area
Cabins, Rustic homes
Average Home Prices in the Custer Gallatin National Forest Area
* Buying: $200,000 – $300,000
* Renting: $1,000 – $1,500/month
Caldwell Road Area

(Image for illustration purposes only.)
The Caldwell Road Area offers a mix of suburban and rural life with spacious homes and plenty of outdoor space. It's great for those who want a bit of both worlds.
Characteristics of the Caldwell Road Area
* Culture: Family-oriented community, suburban activities
* Transportation: Accessible roads, primarily car travel
* Services: Local parks, playgrounds, and nearby services
* Environment: Lively and family-friendly
Housing Options in the Caldwell Road Area
Suburban homes, Country-style houses
Average Home Prices in the Caldwell Road Area
* Buying: $275,000 – $375,000
* Renting: $1,200 – $1,800/month
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Residential Areas in Fishtail:
The best residential areas in Fishtail include Fishtail Village, Fishtail Creek Area, Yellowstone Valley Area, Rocky Mountain Estates, Custer Gallatin National Forest Area, and Caldwell Road Area.
Fishtail Village and Rocky Mountain Estates are most recommended for families due to their community services and amenities.
The Custer Gallatin National Forest Area tends to have more affordable housing options compared to others.
Fishtail offers grocery stores, local parks, schools, and cafés, with more amenities available in Fishtail Village.
Yes, having a car is highly recommended as public transportation options are limited.
The Custer Gallatin National Forest Area offers the most direct access to outdoor activities like hiking, camping, and wildlife observation.
The average home prices in Fishtail range from $200,000 to $500,000 depending on location and type of property.
Yes, there are schools available within Fishtail Village and surrounding areas, making it convenient for families.
The lifestyle in Fishtail is peaceful and community-oriented, with numerous outdoor activities and a relaxed pace of living.
Fishtail has a temperate climate with warm summers and cold winters, making it ideal for year-round outdoor activities.
Conclusion on the Best Residential Areas in Fishtail:
Fishtail, Montana, presents a unique blend of community spirit, natural beauty, and outdoor adventure, making it an ideal place for various lifestyles. From the vibrant atmosphere of Fishtail Village to the peaceful retreats offered by the Fishtail Creek Area and Custer Gallatin National Forest, there is something for everyone in this charming town. Families will appreciate the services and community focus, while nature enthusiasts will revel in the accessibility to outdoor activities. Ultimately, choosing the right residential area in Fishtail depends on personal preferences regarding community, tranquility, and amenities. Regardless of your choice, Fishtail provides a welcoming and fulfilling living experience.
About the Author

Published by:Eribert De Oliveira
Mechatronics Engineer and founder of Mi Inmueble Online, with a background in real estate. I combine technology and analysis to help you find the best areas to live.